The European Green Bond Standard (EU-GBS)

05/10/23

In Brief

The development of sustainable finance within the financial industry implies certain adjustments of priorities as well as clear and objective guidelines leading financial players and investments decisions. Sustainable, green and social risks and criteria have become essential considerations for financial players constantly seeking further guidance from the legislator.

In March 2018, the European Commission published its Action Plan on Financing Sustainable Growth (Sustainable Action Plan) to set out a comprehensive strategy including (i) the development of unified classification system for sustainable economic activities, (ii) a European Union (EU) Green Bond Standard, (iii) benchmarks for low-carbon investments strategies and (iv) guidance to improve corporate disclosure of climate-related information. The EU GBS is therefore part of a bigger puzzle rather than just being a self-standing initiative.

After years of debates and discussions, the European Green Bond Regulation1, introducing the European Green Bond Standard (EU-GBS) was adopted on 5 October 2023 by the European Parliament and became applicable after approval by the Council. The text has been published in the Official Journal of the EU and entered into force on 21 December 2023. It will start applying as from 21 December 2024 as the Regulation includes a transitional period of 1 year.

Through the introduction of a voluntary standard enhancing the effectiveness, transparency and credibility of the European green bond market, the EU aims to remove any outstanding hurdle preventing issuers from raising funds to invest in green projects and assets.  

The EU being the main driver for Green Bond issuances, it was of the utmost importance for the European legislator to develop and implement a standard backed-up by a regulation directly applicable throughout the EU jurisdictions. Although, the EU GBS structure is built on its predecessor market-based standards (ICMA Green Bond Principles 2 and the CBI Climate Bonds Standards3), it also differs in aiming to enhance transparency, integrity, consistency and comparability, by tying up its requirements to those of other Sustainable Finance related European regulations and directives - i.e. the European Taxonomy regulation4 (EU Taxonomy), the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation5 (SFDR) and the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive6 (CSRD). Moreover, to prevent greenwashing in the Green Bonds market in general, the EU GBS also provides for some voluntary disclosure requirements for other environmentally sustainable bonds and sustainability-linked bonds issued in the EU to improve transparency and investor trust.

1 Regulation (EU) 2023/2631 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 November 2023 available on https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:L_202302631

2 ICMA, The Green Bond Principles – Voluntary Process Guidelines for Issuing Green Bonds, June 2021 (with June 2022 Appendix I) available on International Finance Corporation

3 Climate Bonds Standard, Globally recognised, Paris-aligned certification of Debt Instruments, Entities and Assets using robust science-based methodologies, updated April 2023, version 4.0 available on https://www.climatebonds.net/files/files/CBI_Standard_V4.pdf

4 Regulation (EU) 2020/852 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 June 2020 on the establishment of a framework to facilitate sustainable investment available on https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A32020R0852

5 Regulation (EU) 2019/2088 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 November 2019 on sustainability-related disclosures in the financial services sector available on https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2019/2088/oj

Directive (EU) 2022/2464 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 December 2022 available on https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32022L2464

The EU GBS checklist from an issuer perspective

eu gps

01. General Requirements

 

The EU GBS ensures that bond issuances are labelled and aligned with the EU’s environmental and climate objectives. Sustainable investments involve integrating environmental and social considerations into investments decisions which will benefit investors and society more broadly. A significant part of this effort will have to be financed by the private sector.

To operate this green transition, sufficient, clear, reliable, and comparable data is essential to effectively channel capital into sustainable investments and assets. 

The EU Taxonomy is a cornerstone of the EU sustainable framework as well as an important market transparency tool that helps direct investments towards sustainable economic activities. Bonds as debt instruments are mainly used to raise capital for general purposes based on an issuer’s risk profile represented by its credit rating and the remuneration offered as interest paid. Traditionally, investors focus on these criteria rather than on the use of proceeds. Green Bonds represent a natural source of financing for issuers who have a financing or refinancing requirement for green projects. By focusing on the use of proceeds, the EU GBS ensures that any such financing occurs in a manner that is directly linked to the issuer’s sustainability objectives.  

Proceeds from Green Bonds have to finance or refinance economic activities that:

(a) contribute substantially to at least one of the six taxonomy environmental objectives including: 

(i) climate change mitigation; 

(ii) climate change adaptation; 

(iii) the sustainable use and protection of water and marine resources; 

(iv) the transition to a circular economy; 

(v) pollution prevention and control; and 

(vi) the protection and restoration of biodiversity and ecosystems; 

(b) do not significantly harm any of the other objectives (DNSH); 

(c) comply with minimum safeguards7; and

(d) where technical screening criteria have been developed, financed projects or activities shall meet these criteria, allowing however for specific cases where these may not be directly applicable.

The proceeds of European Green Bonds shall be only and fully allocated according to the EU Taxonomy  requirements8 to the following, or a combination thereof fixed assets that are not financial assets, capital expenditures, operating expenditures incurred more recently than three years prior to the issuance of the bonds or financial assets9 provided those assets were created no later than five years after the issuance of the bonds or assets and expenditures of households and the sectors concerned are already covered by the EU Taxonomy and technical screening criteria have been developed in this respect. For those sectors not yet covered by the EU Taxonomy and for certain very specific activities there will be a flexibility pocket of 15% (a portion of the proceeds amounting to maximum 15% of the total issuance can be not EU taxonomy-aligned).

Issuers may allocate proceeds from a portfolio of one or more outstanding Green Bonds to a portfolio of financial assets in which case, they shall demonstrate in the allocation reports that the total value of financial assets in their portfolio exceeds the total value of their portfolio of outstanding Green Bonds.

7 As defined in Article 18 of the European Taxonomy regulation

8 Article 6 of the Green Bond Regulation

Article 4 of the Green Bond Regulation

02. Reporting requirements

Green Bond Factsheet

Prior to issuing Green Bonds, the Green Bond Factsheet (as set out in Annex I of the Green Bond regulation) must be completed. The latter consists of a framework of core components Green Bonds must comply with thereby enhancing transparency, integrity, consistency and comparability of these bonds. 

The Green Bond Factsheet provides information on how the bonds are expected to contribute to the issuer’s broader environmental strategy, the extent to which the proceeds are expected to contribute to the issuer’s EU Taxonomy-aligned assets, turnover, capital expenditure and operating expenditure and the associated environmental impacts. 

It also states in-detail the intended allocation of the bonds proceeds, the estimate of the issuance costs that are deducted from the proceeds, the estimated time until full allocation of the proceeds and the form and content of the reporting.

A pre-issuance review of the Green Bond Factsheet with a positive opinion by an external reviewer is mandatory10

Allocation Report

The Allocation Report must demonstrate how the proceeds of Green Bonds have been allocated to the EU Taxonomy various economic activities (EU Taxonomy aligned, specific EU Taxonomy aligned or not aligned), providing investors with transparent and reliable information. 

A Green Bond Allocation Report may relate to one or several issuances of Green Bonds and shall be drawn up annually at the end of each year until full allocation of the proceeds. 

Where the use of proceeds relate to economic activities that will meet the taxonomy requirements in the future, the issuer shall publish a capital expenditure plan (CapEx Plan)11. The CapEx plan shall specify a deadline by which all the capital and operating expenditures funded by the European green bond shall be taxonomy-aligned, and which shall be set before the European green bond reaches maturity.

The Allocation Report shall contain, where applicable, information on the progress made in the implementation of the CapEx Plan. Issuers shall publish an explanation in the annual Allocation Report if there is a delay or departure that significantly impacts the implementation of the CapEx Plan.

The post-issuance review by an external reviewer shall contain an assessment of whether the issuer has complied with the intended use of proceeds as set out in the Green Bond Factsheet and the EU GBS12.

Issuers shall ensure that the external reviewer has at least 90 days to review an allocation report. The post-issuance review by an external reviewer must be made public within 270 days following the end of the year to which the allocation report refers13

The issuer shall obtain an assessment from an external reviewer about the taxonomy-alignment of capital and operating expenditures that are included in that CapEx plan and funded by the proceeds of that European green bond. The assessment shall be provided by the external reviewer within 60 days.

Impact Report 

The Impact Report discloses the alignment of the bonds' environmental impact associated with the activities funded by the proceeds of the bonds issued.

The Impact Report must be published at least once during the lifetime of the bond after the full allocation of the proceeds (as set out in Annex III of the Green Bond Regulation)14. A single impact report may cover several issuances of bonds15.

An external review of the impact report may be obtained but is not mandatory.

The external review of the Impact Report contains an assessment of whether the bond issuance aligns with the broader environmental strategy of the issuer, an assessment of the indicated environmental impact of the bond proceeds and compliance with the EU GBS.

10  Article 8 §3 of the Green Bond Regulation.

11  Article 6 of the Green Bond Regulation.

12  Article 9 §3 of the Green Bond Regulation.

13   Article 9 §6 of the Green Bond Regulation.

14  Article 10 §1 of the Green Bond Regulation.

15  Article 10 §2 of the Green Bond Regulation.

Our view

We believe that the adoption of the EU Green Bond Regulation introducing the EU GBS will be the turning point for debut and repeat Green Bond issuers who want to apply what has been regarded as the long-awaited Golden Standard to be used for Green Bonds issuances and to make a clear statement of being frontrunners in and fully committed to a Sustainable Future. However, to name a few, the requirements for the proceeds being aligned to the EU taxonomy and getting assurance over the DSNH are challenging elements of the EU GBS to be complied with, and it is likely that this voluntary standard will operate alongside ICMA Green Bond Principles and the CBI Climate Bonds Standards for few years to come.